Showing posts with label Rudd. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rudd. Show all posts

Wednesday, 25 November 2009

Rudd’s CPRS won't solve the problem: radical climate action needed now

from the Socialist Alliance website

Simon Butler
25 November 2009

Could the government’s proposed Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme (CPRS) get any worse? The unfortunate answer is yes. It can, it has already and it’s likely to get worse still before parliament ends for the year.

Radical action is needed to avert an irreversible climate change disaster. Australia has some of the best conditions in the world for wind and solar power. An emergency program to phase out fossil fuels and switch to renewable energy in a decade is needed.

Given the crisis, it’s hard to imagine a more useless response than an emissions trading scheme.

Carbon trading schemes now exist in 35 countries worldwide. Yet nowhere have they successfully driven down carbon emissions.

In their various forms, however, all have proved to be highly lucrative for a new breed of carbon speculators, who can profit from trading in a new commodity — our air.

Friends of the Earth said the European Union’s emissions trading scheme will be worth about US$3.1 trillion by 2020.

Such cap-and-trade schemes face increasing criticism as failures mount, but profits — and emissions — rise.

In July, the billionaire financier George Soros told a London School of Economics conference that carbon trading was the wrong response to climate change. “The system can be gamed; that’s why financial types like me like it — because there are financial opportunities.”

Australian climate activists and most environment groups have condemned the proposed CPRS as a woefully inadequate response to the global warming crisis. Its weak targets ignore the scientific evidence that rapid emission cuts are needed.

The federal climate change department’s own figures suggest that the scheme won’t lead to a significant drop in Australia’s emissions for at least 20 years. Climate scientists say that’s far too late to prevent runaway climate change.

The low targets are a ghastly joke in the face of a looming climate disaster. But even worse, they are not real targets at all.

The CPRS will allow business to meet the emissions cuts targets through buying carbon offsets from overseas — that is, they can pay projects in other countries to make 100% of the cuts on their behalf.

The scheme gives A$16.4 billion taxpayers’ money as “compensation” to polluting industries, diverting resources away from direct investment in solar thermal, and wind power, energy efficiency measures and public transport.

The proposed payouts have grown so large the federal treasury was forced to revise its revenue projections for the CPRS on November 2, the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF) said. Treasury now expects it will be $2.5 billion in arrears by 2019-20.

Critics also point out the scheme’s subsidies will keep polluting industries in business, rather than phase them out.

In its first year, the CPRS carbon price will be capped at $10 a tonne — a rate so low it’s certain to price renewable energy alternatives out of the market.

So much for the supposed ecological benefits of a “free market” in pollution.

The only thing truly “free” in this scheme is the 95% of permits the government will hand to the dirtiest and richest companies at no charge.

The climate depravity of the two big parties is hard to overstate. Negotiations between the ALP and Coalition to get the scheme passed by the Senate are certain to add even more loopholes for the big polluters.

The ALP government has ruled out any negotiations with the Greens, who want far stiffer cuts in emissions.

Emissions from agriculture are the latest casualty of the political horse-trading. Prime Minister Kevin Rudd said on November 15 agriculture would be permanently excluded from the CPRS. It was a key demand of the climate denier-riddled opposition.

After stationary energy, agriculture is the next biggest contributor to Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions.

The plan to cut emissions in this crucial area is now official: we have no plan. But in truth, this is only a marginal change from the Rudd government’s climate policy for other sectors. There we have a plan that is sure to fail.

Other Coalition amendment proposals include: triple compensation payments to electricity producers; lock in the weak targets for 10 years instead of five; and exempt mining companies from having to worry about the release of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, from coalmines.

At least some of these proposals will become part of the final legislation if it is to pass into law.

A question arises as to whether the big environmental NGOs, who were suckered into backing the CPRS in May, will now finally distance themselves from the polluter-friendly scheme.

The ACF has said many times it would end its support of the CPRS if it was “substantially weakened”. Yet the exclusion of agriculture from the CPRS — amounting to about 16% of Australia’s emissions — still hasn’t led to a policy change.

As the circus surrounding the CPRS draws to its miserable finale, new evidence of the looming climate catastrophe has emerged. It is almost as if the warnings from climate scientists become more dire in inverse proportion to the worsening of Australia’s climate change policy.

On November 20, parts of New South Wales were placed on “catastrophic fire danger” alerts. South-eastern Australia braced for more days of searing heat and fierce winds.

Meanwhile, a new study published in the journal Nature Geoscience by a group of climate scientists from the Global Carbon Project said average temperatures are highly likely to rise by 6°C by the end of the century.

The scientists assessed that such a rise was probable given current emissions. The study said world emissions rose 28% between 2000 and 2008. In the 18 years from 1990, the rise was 41%.

They also confirmed the rate of emissions is now higher than ever — at a time it should be coming down fast. In the 1990s, emissions rose by about 1% a year. Since the turn of the century, the yearly rise has been about 3%.

The November 18 London Independent pointed out that a 6°C rise “would have cataclysmic and irreversible consequences for the Earth, making large parts of the planet uninhabitable and threatening the basis of human civilisation”.

Lead author of the study, Professor Corinne Le Quere, told the Independent December’s Copenhagen climate talks had to make a strong commitment to cut emissions.

“If the agreement is too weak, or the commitments not respected, it is not 2.5°C or 3°C we will get: it's 5°C or 6°C — that is the path we're on”, she said.

But any hopes that the Copenhagen conference will deliver the agreement the planet so desperately needs are misplaced.

US President Barack Obama announced on November 14 that no legally binding agreement would be made — exactly what the rich countries, including Australia, have pushed for over the past few months, against the wishes of the poor nations. The setting of binding targets will be delayed for at least a year.

In a display of outrageous hypocrisy, Rudd called on world leaders to show greater “political courage” at Copenhagen, said ABC Online on November 18.

Real political courage is exactly what is required. But it won’t be found in the pro-corporate political parties or the international gatherings of the so-called world leaders, who will lead us only to oblivion.

The political courage we need is the courage of the street, of the activists, of the people. The courage to fight for the measures we need and not give up. The courage to take decision-making power out of the hands of the elites who have so grievously abused it.

The courage to tell the truth about climate change. The courage to demand what science and justice dictate, not what is desperately inadequate but “politically acceptable”.

The courage to keep building a movement that can make governments fear the people, and fear the consequences of just pretending to act on climate change any longer.

That kind of political courage is all that stands between a safe climate future and climate chaos.

Thursday, 5 February 2009

Hamilton: climate emergency or a crisis of democracy?

From Crikey, WEDNESDAY 4 FEBRUARY 2009

Clive Hamilton writes:

When the authorities put the figures together, the death rates in Melbourne and Adelaide will show a spike in response to the record temperatures over Eastern Australia last week.

As in the European heatwave of August 2003, when 35,000 people died, the elderly are most vulnerable as the heat overwhelms the body’s natural cooling mechanism and organs fail. Swamped by the disaster, undertakers in France were obliged to take over a refrigerated warehouse on the outskirts of Paris.

Across central France the temperature reached 40°C, and in Britain 38.5°C, or 100 degrees under the old scale, an all-time record.

In Melbourne and Adelaide last week temperatures of 44 and 45°C were recorded. Forty is the new thirty. One night in Adelaide the minimum temperature was 34°C, perhaps the first time the city has experienced a nocturnal scorcher.

In Melbourne the wail of ambulance sirens was heard up and down every high street. Brush-tailed possums expired and fell out of the trees.

Australians are already dying from climate change. As Professor David Karoly, one of our most respected climate scientists, said: “The system can’t cope now, and it is just going to get much worse”.

Anyone who is not very scared about global warming is not listening to what the scientists are telling us. It is not enough to be vaguely worried.

The scientists are telling us we have only a few years left for global emissions to peak, then decline sharply, if we are to avoid catastrophe. But now the widely agreed ‘safe’ level of warming, 2°C above pre-industrial levels, has been challenged because even that amount won’t prevent summer sea-ice in the Arctic from melting, with knock-on effects in Greenland and the Siberian permafrost.

If he serves two or three terms, by the end of Mr Rudd’s time in office it will be too late to get serious about warming. His Clayton’s emissions trading system, which rewards big polluters for polluting, is nowhere near what the science demands and is better rejected outright.

When the world’s scientists concluded before the Bali conference that rich countries must cut their emissions by 25-40 per cent by 2020 if we are to have a good chance of stabilising at 2°C of warming, they were not putting in an ambit claim.

Yet when the Prime Minister says, as he has more than once, that his task is to ‘balance’ the claims of industry and the sceptics against those of the scientists and environmentalists he is saying that the scientists are political actors and the facts of climate science are up for negotiation. Echoing the post-modern approach to truth, Mr Rudd seems to believe that the science is not objective but relative and contestable.

The election of Labor at the end of 2007 seemed like a breakthrough; after all, climate change was one of the three big points of difference between Labor and the conservatives.

For years I have written about the extraordinary power of the self-described greenhouse mafia in Canberra, yet even I believed that its influence was on the wane because it had over-played its hand under Howard. How wrong I was.

It was apparent early in 2008 that behind the scenes the fossil fuel lobby was organising. They martialled their troops and rearmed themselves with arguments, fighting funds, lobbyists and dodgy economic studies.

They rebuilt their networks in government and the public service, insinuated themselves into policy processes, schmoozed back-benchers and dined privately with ministers and their staff. They whispered about how important the old energy industries are to the economy, how Labor voters value their jobs, and how they will take their business offshore. And always hanging in the air was the unspoken threat that if the Government went too far they would unleash the most virulent campaign to punish it.

So 2008 saw the new government run from its commitment to be a bold leader on climate. Contrary to Kevin Rudd’s declaration to the world at Bali, in 2009 Australia does not stand ready to assume its responsibility and his Government is not prepared to take on the challenge and deliver a sustainable future.

It turns out that Peter Garrett’s indiscrete prediction before the election that “once we get in we’ll just change it all” has come to pass, except that instead of pursuing a bold secret agenda the Rudd Government has reneged on its promises. Instead of going too far, as the conservatives feared, it has not gone far enough.

The climate emergency has turned into a crisis of democracy. The government is meant to protect the interests of the people, but it has instead protected the interests of the big polluters. The Government is in the thrall of a powerful group of energy companies and it is apparent even to the most dim-witted observer that these corporations are, as Thoreau wrote, “more interested in commerce than humanity”.

The scientists are beginning to understand that human-induced climate change has disturbed a sleeping giant. Mr Rudd’s belief that he, along with other leaders, can legislate to tame it is reminiscent of a syndrome Marx called ‘parliamentary cretinism’.

Paraphrasing Engels, parliamentary cretinism is an aliment whose unfortunate victims are permeated by the lofty conviction that the future of the world is determined by a majority of votes of the institution that has the honour of having them as members.

The announcement of the Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme was a king hit on the mainstream environment groups that had invested so much in working on the inside of the parliamentary process. Seduced into believing they can influence the Government, in truth they were crushed by the greenhouse mafia. Fossil fuel delegations could get an hour of quality time with the minister, while environment groups felt lucky to have 15 minutes with a bored staffer.

This failure underlines the importance of the ‘new environment movement’, a surprisingly large network of community-based activist groups that came together in Canberra last weekend for the Climate Action Summit.

Led by a new generation of young people whose politics have not been shaped by the old movement, they represent a return to radical activism. They are determined, angry, savvy and brave.

They believe that baby boomers are bequeathing to them a world much worse than the one the boomers inherited. Their objective was perfectly captured in the words on a T-shirt worn by one of them: “Unf-ck the world”.

Clive Hamilton is the author of Scorcher: The dirty politics of climate change (Black Inc.)
Update: Clive Hamilton takes on Tim Flannery at Crikey.

Monday, 20 October 2008

“End the NT Intervention”: ARC Forum Nov 1

“DEFEND ABORIGINAL COMMUNITIES, FROM ‘THE BLOCK’ TO THE TOP END!”

Aboriginal activists and other speakers take a critical look at Rudd’s Review Panel Report on the on the NT Intervention, the continuation of attacks on welfare and the need to resist racist attacks on Aboriginal Communities in Sydney as well as the NT

2pm – 4pm Saturday 1st November

Redfern Community, Centre Hugo St, Redfern

For more information, ring Greg 0432 050 240 or email aboriginalrightscoalition@gmail.com

The Aboriginal Rights Coalition, Sydney, meets every Monday at 6pm @ the Redfern Community Centre. Please come along and join the campaign for justice.

If you can’t make the meetings, please consider donating to help the ARC cover our costs. Whether it be travel costs for speakers, photocopying, food or venue hire, the ARC is a volunteer organisation, and depends upon your help to continue.

http://aboriginalrightscoalition.wordpress.com/

Sunday, 8 June 2008

Rudd, Poverty and the Rise of the Underclass

In a good article in today's Sydney Morning Herald, Kerry-Anne Walsh hits upon the worst-kept secret at the heart of Australian society and the economic "boom" of the past decade. Despite all the talk of economic growth, behind all the bluster and blow about interest rates, the rhetoric about "working families" and cutting fuel excise, there is the reality of a growing impoverished underclass in Australia. As Walsh writes:

“THERE is something terribly wrong in a rich country of only 21 million people when 2 million were driven last financial year to seek help from social services.”

Her article is a response to the contents of the annual Australian Community Sector Survey (ACCS), released on Friday. The ACCS found a 6.3% increase in the number of people assisted by community service agencies in the year 2006-7, as well as a 24% increase in those turned away from the services they needed and were eligible for. The survey also found:


There is more, though not in that report. At least ten percent of the population is undeniably living in poverty (a figure which is more likely double that in reality). Over 39 percent of those over 65 years old live below the poverty line, as do most students. And the numbers are worse for aboriginal Australia.

As if this weren't enough, well over 100,000 people in Australia are homeless (including at least 36,000 youth), when there are – in Sydney alone – over 122,211 buildings being kept empty, artificially and deliberately out of public reach in order to fulfill the whims of the market.

Another estimated 300,000 households are under severe mortgage stress, with Australian households owing an average 160 percent of their disposable income. Renters face the unenviable situation of rents that have risen by over 80 percent since 1996. And let’s not talk about how many private properties ministers in the NSW government own!

Then, of course, we have to deal with interest rates, food prices, (we are now promised in NSW) public transport costs and other basics costs of living all increasing – not to mention the environmental crisis, and the effects it will have. And the devil-may-care capitalist banditry of the privatisation-happy NSW government under Iemma and Costa, and their co-thinkers around the country.

Walsh correctly points to the idiocy of bragging in these circumstances about a $22 billion dollar surplus, but – all things considered – her blows against the government fall a bit soft. She rightly takes them up on the spin-cycle nature of politics, and calls upon them to do better. But is it likely that this mob of charlatans will?

Rudd and Co. continue to manage the capitalist system here exactly the way big business wants it, providing little more than the necessary rhetoric - circuses but no bread - to placate a population still exhaling a massive sigh of relief after the Howard Years. A call to arms Walsh’s article was not – but it should be.

While the Rudd government continues to throw around fluffy words, ideas and phrases - talking of working people "tightening belts", pretending to act on climate change, calling for job cuts to prevent interest rate increases, and promising mealy-mouthed (and economically irrational) actions like setting up “FuelWatch” or cutting the tax on fuel - the reality is quite simple, and not just a little dire.

It's the kind of situation that makes you want to update "History will absolve me", and storm, say, Puckapunyal military barracks a la Fidel Castro.

Quite obviously failing that, we need a political alternative with some backbone, and a willingness to call it how it is. To, as Walsh puts it, “move above such tasteless proposals that a government should forgo $2 billion a year in petrol taxes to give a Vegemite sandwich in relief to those who can actually afford to run a car.”

In a society that tolerates wealthy parasites like former Macquarie Bank CEO Alan Moss giving themselves $60 million golden handshakes, this kind of change isn’t going to happen if we sit and wait on the mainstream parties to step up to the plate, and it’s not going to happen without a fight.

Of course, Socialist Alliance recognises the need for urgent action, as do numerous others - individuals and groups alike. But it's one thing to have policy and pithy responses: link 1; link 2; link 3; link 4; link 5; and it's another to find ways to implement it. We still need a stronger, more united, left to make this possible - both red, and green, and perhaps other colours too. If the left can't see past it's organisational and programmatic shibboleths, and start working together in the face of these facts (not to mention the climate crisis) then it is condemning itself to irrelevance. Unfortunately, that struggle for left unity remains the one of the biggest - and most important - challenges we face today.


Finally, in case you missed it, the 7:30 Report's Clark and Dawe have nicely captured the nonsense of Rudd's economic conservatism with regards to the (or any) budget surplus. The transcript can be found here: Clarke and Dawe and a tale of two economies.

Friday, 9 May 2008

Marcus Strom - "Maintain the link, defend the pledge"


Unions are the bedrock of the Labor Party, writes Marcus Strom

from Labor Tribune

Will no one rid me of these troublesome unions? So must be the thoughts of NSW Premier Morris Iemma.

The stoush over electricity privatisation is turning out to be a dress rehearsal for a showdown over a more fundamental issue: the future of the link between organised workers and the Australian Labor Party.

The first shots in this battle under a Rudd government came from Mark Aarons, Iemma's former hired hand. His essay in Dear Mr Rudd has described union power in the ALP as so pernicious that it "threatens to grow into a cancer''. He recommends limiting union representation to the party conference in line with affiliate union density, at about 12 per cent. ALP branch membership has fallen below 50,000. Yet unions affiliated to the ALP make up more than 1 million people; that's roughly 90 per cent of membership with 50 per cent of conference vote.

There is no doubt the union link needs to be democratised, but diminution is not the answer. Political parties are not microcosms of all society, they are voluntary affiliations of a broad range of people committed to pursing common political ends. They percolate and crystallise ideas into a shared agenda. Traditionally in Australia, this has been along a right-left class line. With the Australian Labor Party, there is a bit of a clue in the name. Unions formed this party and remain its bedrock.

However, the message from the managerial elite of Labor - the staffers, hacks and careerists - is that the business of politics would be a lot easier if our parliamentary representatives did not have to kowtow to these unions.

On top of this is the stink about corporate donations and the push for state-funded election campaigns. Hand-outs from developers and the hotel lobby have become politically unsustainable. If the ALP is forced to give up the corporate cash cow, it will become more reliant on union funds. For Iemma and Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, that is not on. But to remove the unions from the equation creates a financial problem for the ALP. Enter state funding for elections. From the corporate teat to the state bottle.

To achieve this seismic shift the ALP machine will need an ideological package. This partly explains the national executive's move to revisit the party's pledge to democratic socialism.

Every year at ALP state conference, delegates go through a little charade. One branch or other recommends removal of the party's commitment to democratic socialism. Some more modern, neutral words such as fair-go, equality, solidarity are suggested. And every year the party's hierarchy recommends its rejection, all in the interest of party unity.

But not this year.

Last weekend the Georges Hall branch submitted a motion calling for the scrapping of the party's socialist pledge. Rather than recommend rejection, the rules committee suggested conference "refer to the ALP national executive for consideration in the forthcoming Review of the Party Pledge''.

This is the first time most party members will have heard of any such review, but it should come as no surprise. Rudd has emphatically rejected this aspect of Labor's heritage: "I am not a socialist. I have never been a socialist and I never will be a socialist.'' (The Age, December 14, 2006)

Troublesome unions, controversy over corporate funding and the review of the socialist pledge: together this is a recipe to attain what even Tony Blair could not fully achieve in Britain the delabourisation of Labor and the establishment of a centrist liberal party without the unions.

This outcome echoes ALP assistant state secretary Luke Foley's concerns as voiced on Four Corners (Dirty, Sexy Money, April 14). "If we're simply a brand with a good advertising campaign every time an election comes round and nothing else, we only engage in the empty pursuit of power.''

Elections and democracy will be seen as an even more stage-managed affair on behalf of the state and the "urban elites''. Cynicism of the political process will increase. Citizen involvement will decline.

What is at stake is not only the democratic heart of the Labor Party, but the very fabric of our democracy. Without active citizen participation in the political process, what sort of democracy is it? We cannot afford to let a managerial elite cut itself free of civil society and hook up to a self-perpetuating state-government-party funding cycle.

Of course the funding process needs radical reform. The corporate donations must stop and the process must be transparent. Donations and declarations must be simultaneous. Further we need participation of party members and beyond that an active and engaged citizenry; we need accountability of our representatives and ALP members deserve accountability within the party. For a start, rather than union secretaries appointing their delegates to state conference, we should move to rank and file election.

Let's not contemplate abandoning the pledge or ending the union link. Let's work to make it stronger, democratic and accountable.

Marcus Strom is secretary of the Summer Hill branch of the ALP and editor of Labor Tribune

This article originally appeared on crikey.com.au on May 7, 2008

Thursday, 17 April 2008

Don’t wait until 2010 – Abolish the ABCC now!

Don’t wait until 2010 – Abolish the ABCC now!

Since it was set up in 2005, the Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC) has operated as an all-powerful secret police in the building industry, attacking unions, unionists and the right to organise. The ABCC has been handed dictatorial power to secretly interrogate and intimidate workers, to jail and levy huge fines, all in the interest of defending profits in the building industry. The new Rudd government must honour its commitment to abolish the ABCC, not in 2010 but now! Any proposal to introduce a new “tough cop on the beat”, as proposed by deputy PM Julia Gillard in the lead-up to the 2007 federal election, must also be dropped.


The ABCC was set up as the Howard government's special weapon against the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, especially after its critical role in defeating Howard's attack on the Maritime Union of Australia in the 1998 Patrick's dispute. It was formed out of the Cole Royal Commission into the building industry – a trumped-up kangaroo court, which failed to find any evidence of any corruption by building unions. It aims to intimidate union members, bankrupt and split unions, and destroy all workplace solidarity. $32 million a year of taxpayers' money goes to keeping this special cop shop running.


The Commission’s extraordinary powers allow it to operate in secrecy, deny workers the right to silence and impose hefty fines and prison sentences for non-cooperation. No other group of workers in Australia has been singled out to face the draconian and unjust force of the law to such an extent. Already three reports by the International Labour Organisation have been issued outlining how the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act, the Howard government legislation which formed the ABCC, is in breach of international labor law.


The ABCC has been involved in around 38 prosecutions targeting workers and unions who have taken industrial action over occupational health and safety concerns, in particular, including life-threatening workplace issues. Under the current laws the building industry is defined so broadly that it also includes transport and manufacturing workers, making them targets for the building industry’s attack dog. The ABCC’s target list includes the CFMEU, the Electrical Trades Union, the Australian Manufacturing Workers Union and the MUA.


Since the election of the Rudd government in November, the ABCC has been pursuing building workers with an increased frenzy. This points to a broader campaign by big business to create the impression of “industrial chaos” in the building industry in order justify the ABCC’s existence beyond Labor’s stated end-date of January 1, 2010. In particular, the charging in Geelong of CFMEU delegate Craig Johnston–former state secretary of the Australian Manufacturing Workers Union – is a cynical attempt to revive anti-union hysteria by stirring memories of "unionists on the rampage" (when Johnston's "crime" as a union official was trying to defend unjustly sacked AMWU members!).


The bitter truth is that–contrary to election promises and much empty rhetoric–the Rudd Federal government wants to keep most of the previous Coalition government’s anti-worker laws. While promising to abolish the ABCC, Labor will replace it with a special section of its “Fair Work Australia”, which may have similar powers to the ABCC. This is an outrage. The ABCC needs to be completely abolished and discrimination against building workers ended once and for all!


No secret police for the building industry!
No more kangaroo courts – abolish the ABCC now!
Defend the right to organise!
Defend the right to strike!

Friday, 28 March 2008

WorkChoices and Neoliberalism by any other name...


Deputy Prime Minister Julia Gillard donned the dark frocks for a funeral today - the (hopefully) final laying to rest of the Bad Boy of WorkChoices: Australian Workplace Agreements (AWAs). The Governor-General gave the things their lethal injection la night, and they were put to sleep, and then - on the second anniversary of WorkChoices - they were finally relegated to the dustbin of history.

Well, new ones, that is. There are still apparently upward of 1 million of the little bastards floating around, and many may not end until 2013. Worse yet, the ALP's "Forward With Fairness" policy replacement isn't really so different to WorkChoices itself, leading many unionists and those on the left to call it "WorkChoices Lite" - and with good reason. The wombats are waiting for many a bubble to burst on that front. Hopefully it won't take too long (although it could be helped along in a couple of ways).

The ALP is making no immediately obvious moves to get rid of the ABCC either - the star-chamber empowered secret police for the building industry, which has already been responsible for gross violations of civil liberties, not to mention being a centrepiece in the ongoing attacks on workers' rights in general. It won't be scrapped until 2010. And even if they remove it, they are likely to replace it with something not too dissimilar (if a little cuddlier).

You might be forgiven for thinking that, what with the ALP in power in all states and federally, we might be set for some meaningful changes. Well, maybe there'll be some changes, but it depends what kind of changes you are looking for. And with NSW Labor's heart set on privatising the state's energy supply (soon to be followed by the ferries, the lottery, perhaps the oxygen?) the true stripes of Labor can be seen.

Against around 80 percent public opposition to the sell-off, against their own party platform, and against the rebellion of the unions and over a dozen of the Government's own MPs, Iemma and Costa insist that come hell or high-water (and let's not get started with the idiocy of a desalination plant, and all the back-room deals involved in that one) they will follow through with the sell-off.

Fortunately, we have a new federal Labor government, which can remind the state government what the "party of labour" should be all about. Right? Well, apparently not. Rudd has also come out in support of Iemma and Co, which must feel relieved to get some kind of support after all the sex-scandals and exposure of dodgy developer deals in Wollongong, and pedophile ministers, and collapsible tunnels, and so on and so forth, which have plagued Premier Iemma since he was handed the poisoned chalice by Bob Carr as the latter trundled off to his retirement job of running NSW from Macquarie Bank proper (instead of just its political wing - the NSW ALP).

So ok. Maybe Rudd isn't the white knight some might have hoped for (even if he is going to inject money into the Murray). But Labor got in on the back of a genuine tidal wave of support, not a small part of which was around the opposition to WorkChoices, organised by the ACTU and others in the form of the "Your Rights At Work" campaign. So surely the hero of the labour movement, the real "people's champion" of the election - former ACTU Secretary Greg Combet - can be relied upon to see what's right and what's not, and stick up for the people, for common sense and for the planet (given the likely need for government control of energy production in order to prevent runaway Climate Change).

Ummm. No, actually. As even Bob Gould points out, Combet has counted his cards, and is relying - along with the rest of the Labor Left - upon a friendly deal from Poker-face Rudd to land the right bums on seats in cabinet. So, not a lot has changed in the "bump-me-into-parliament" world of the ALP's stranglehold on the unions and labour bureacracy. And not even the fact that his own electorate will be hard-hit by the sell-off can make him budge. "Angry voters" about as non-metaphysical as it gets for politicians, yet even that apparently wasn't enough of a carrot.

The shining light - if it can be called that - is the staunch opposition of the Unions NSW leadership to the coming privatisation, to the point of taking it to the floor of the NSW ALP state conference in early May, where they are planning to win. What is less clear, however, is what they plan to do if they win on the conference floor, and Costa then goes ahead with the sale. Gould has been railing of late against the demons he sees lurking in every left-wing critique of the ALP of calls for the expulsion of Iemma and Costa from the ALP.

Now, the wombats have no illusion that that will happen, but
we wonder, then, what will happen when (if?) the vote goes against the government, and they still go ahead. It certainly challenges the logic of those (such as Gould, who certainly sees this fight as important, vital even, in the fight for the ALP) on the left in the ALP - and who see it as a vehicle for socialists - if even when the party conference, the party platform, AND the unions are on your side, you can't make the bastards budge.

Over a hundred years ago, the Australian Socialist League (ASL), and other socialists, put their hopes in elected representatives of the labour movement to bring about socialism in short order. Time and again they were disappointed by their elected Labor MPs, who took any and every opportunity to sell out - fast. Against all reason, however, they maintained a faith that it was a matter of individuals, not of the larger socialist strategy of the day, that was at fault, and that if only the "right people" were elected, all would be fine. And it got worse once the ALP-proper was set up.

Little appears to have changed in the interim, and socialists in Australia are faced with an unpleasant choice of working within the ALP - the perceived "real party of labour" - and having your efforts marginalised and your representatives bought off, or working outside Labor, in a party or a manner that doesn't mean apologism for neoliberal governments, but with the popular, and well-funded, monolith of the ALP to contend with.

And for those of us outside Labor - in the Socialist Alliance, in other socialist groups, in the Greens, the unions and elsewhere - we are faced with the equally daunting task. The task of overcoming a neoliberal ALP's hegemony over the Australian working class, of acheiving the kind of political and organisational unity necessary to
create a viable alternative political vehicle of the working class in Australia. A vehicle which will be capable of bringing about something which has seldom - in the century since the ASL, SDF, ASB, VSP and other early socialists thought it so inevitable - seemed so far away as it does today: "socialism in our time".

This challenge is one which requires us all to rise above sectarianism and personal spite, and honestly appraise the situations before us when searching for answers - the right-wing nature of the new federal ALP government, the very real success of the Your Rights At Work campaign (and the expectations this has sown in many people), the limited but still tangible success of the Socialist Alliance,
and the rise and rise (and worrying contradictions) of the Greens coupled with the importance and surging vitality of the struggle to prevent runaway climate change.

One good place for us all to start would be the Climate Change | Social Change Conference in Sydney on April 11-13, which will feature many of the key players in the various struggles mentioned above - both from Australia and from around the world. But the question of revolutionary strategy, of how to go beyond the limitations of the current juncture, is an ongong one. It is one which the Socialist Alliance was formed to help answer, but we certainly can't (and certainly don't intend to) answer it alone. We need your assistance in that, dear reader.

Thursday, 28 February 2008

Rip up ALL anti-worker laws! Motion calling on Rudd government

Motion calling on the Rudd government to repeal all anti-union laws
[This motion was put to the AMWU Brisbane delegates meeting, held on Tuesday, February 26. The motion will go to AMWU National Conference later this year]

Preamble
The Rudd Labor government came to power on the back of a massive upsurge of working people who took mass action on the streets and campaigned tirelessly through Your Rights at Work and other community groups for the repeal of all of Work Choices.
The backlash was so great that the Howard government was voted out and even John Howard lost his own seat.
Now is the time for the Rudd-led ALP government to deliver on its promise to workers and get rid of all of Work Choices and all anti-union laws.

This [name of union or community group] calls on the federal Labor Government to:

1. Abolish Australian Workplace Agreements (AWAs)
- Backdate the abolition of Australian Workplace Agreements to the date of the ALP’s election victory, November 24, 2007
- No AWA clones! Abandon legislation for Interim Transitional Employment Agreements (ITEAs).
- Allow workers covered by existing AWAs to opt out and to move onto union negotiated Enterprise Bargaining Agreements (EBA) awards.
2. End “prohibited content” in EBAs
3. Reinstate strong awards for all workers (no award stripping)
Awards must include:
- The protection of all penalty rates, loading rates and allowances
- Full wage indexation
- Protection of shift arrangements and rosters
4. Reinstate unfair dismissal laws for all workers immediately. No delay until 2010
- No watered-down system of “conciliation”
- Restore all lost rights
5. Guarantee that all legislation abide by ILO conventions on workers’ rights to freedom of association including
- Union officials right of entry to workplaces
- Workers right to elect workplace delegates
- Workers right to strike, without the threat of fines
- Repeal the ban on industry-wide (pattern) bargaining
6. Abolish the Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC)
7. Abolish the anti-union powers of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC)

MOVED……………………………………………………………………………………..

SECONDED………………………………………………………………………………..


To download the Socialist Alliance's leaflet "Now really rip up WorkChoices", click here.

Friday, 15 February 2008

"Andrew Bolt, Please Forgive Us"

The Wombats will be following this up with an account of the week's actions, activities and agonies in the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander movement, as well a more theoretical piece on the question of resolving the issues still very outstanding. For the moment, however, it seems appropriate to repost this excellent piece, originally from New Matilda, swiping the outraged smirk off the faces of the lunar right.

Satire 15 Feb 2008
Andrew Bolt, Please Forgive Us!
By Ben Pobje

Ben Pobjie offers his apologies to the traditional owners of the Herald Sun opinion pages

The Herald Sun's esteemed opinion columnist, Andrew Bolt, is upset. Very, very upset. Prime Minister Kevin Rudd's apology to Indigenous Australians seems to have set something off in the poor fellow. He's so apoplectic with rage he's started making sheep noises. And I have to say, I feel a little bad for him. He just seems so furious, so desolate at the way the country's going. And the fact is, we're to blame. You and me, and our fellow left-wing, do-gooder, bleeding-heart PC Australians. We've given poor old Andrew heartburn. And at a time like this, I think it's only appropriate that I offer, on behalf of the nation, an apology to Mr Bolt.

Andrew, I'm sorry that, as you say, the Prime Minister offered an apology to stolen generations "no one can actually find". Many of us found quite a lot of them, actually. There were a fair few up in Canberra the other day, in fact. I'm truly sorry you still can't find them. Maybe you could ask your friend Ms O'Donoghue to help you look.

I'm sorry that any of us have the temerity to suggest that Australians might, once, somewhere, somehow, done something for racist reasons. I'm sorry on behalf of all those people who keep talking about "stolen generations" rather than "rescued by kindly European philanthropists generations". I'm sorry such an acceptance of history reduces you to such bitter tears of affronted patriotism. And I'm sorry that it was us, the people of Australia, who wilfully and deliberately accepted that history without the slightest regard for your feelings. We are sorry.

I'm sorry that you think an email from Victorian Education Minister Bronwyn Pike encouraging schools to mark the day of the apology seems to you to be equivalent to turning our children into ‘Red Guards'. I am deeply sorry for the hurt and anguish your paranoia and Cold War fantasies must be causing you. I apologise, on behalf of Ms Pike, for the suggestion that schools should "acknowledge" the day. In future, on occasions of historical import, we will all do our best to completely ignore what's going on. Like we did back when the Aboriginal children were being stolen, which, again, I would like to apologise for mentioning.

I am very, very sorry, Andrew, that you were so upset by the national Sorry. I'm sorry that the sight of the welcoming ceremony cut so deeply into you. I'm sorry for all those deeply offensive tears of joy. I realise now how the spirit of unity and pride, although entered into with good intentions, was in fact unpardonably objectionable and hurtful to the traditional owners of the Herald Sun opinion pages.

But clearly, it's not just the apology that's got you so worked up, Andrew, and I realise we bear responsibility for so much more that's upset the applecart of your life.

So I'm sorry, Andrew, that so many of us lefties act like we don't like you. I'm sorry that Robert Manne and Jon Faine were mean to you. I'm sorry that the rabid left-wing is brainwashing our youth through their awesome power and total domination of the media, and all you get is an entire page to yourself twice a week in the most widely-read daily newspaper in Australia to fight against the massive, unstoppable tide of Marxist lies. I'm sorry that you don't have your own TV show; maybe you and Gerard Henderson could form a support group.

I'm sorry so many of us have bought into the global warming hype; I'm sorry that our political biases have caused us to so blindly follow the relevant science. In addition, I am sorry on behalf of the planet Earth for allowing its climate to change in such a reckless and decidedly politically correct manner. It is possible, I concede, that the planet has undergone warming in response to an email from Bronwyn Pike.

I'm sorry nobody listens to your warnings about Greens being Nazis. I promise that when Bob Brown sets up his first death camp, we're all going to feel really silly.

I'm sorry nobody will listen to the good news about Iraq. I'm sorry we get so fixated on the car-bombs and POW-torture that we neglect the important issues, like all the freedom and democracy floating around, and the soccer team and stuff.

I'm sorry that the culture wars are over. I'm sorry if that makes you feel irrelevant. I know how awful it is for you when you run out of things to fulminate on. I'm sorry if the lack of opportunities to rant about black armbands ends up forcing you into another article about the sinister left-wing agenda of children's cartoons. I apologise sincerely and without qualification for the pain and suffering caused by the political correctness of Finding Nemo. And I'm sorry for those people unkind enough to suggest that someone who considers talking fish a threat to our way of life is less a serious political commentator and more some sort of hilarious caricature of a right-wing lunatic. The suggestion is cruel and unnecessary, and I'm sorry it was ever made.

I'm sorry artists get art grants, and I'm sorry the Liberal Party isn't conservative enough. I'm sorry academics keep disagreeing with you, and I'm sorry there are still people who don't think Christian folk are the best folk in the whole wide world. I'm sorry Victoria was so disgustingly PC as to make a woman Police Commissioner, and I'm sorry there's too much sex on TV. I'm sorry for not being scared enough of Muslims, and I'm sorry for watching Media Watch.

But most of all, Andrew, and I think I speak for all my countrymen and women here, I'm sorry we didn't listen to your warnings. I'm sorry we all lost our minds and voted Labor. And I'm sorry that the country hasn't sunk screaming beneath the ocean as a result. It must really hurt that Kevin hasn't killed us all yet. I'm sorry.

I'm sorry we had the blazing audacity to kick John Howard out. I apologise for our flagrant ingratitude towards him for all he did for us, and to you for all you did for him. I'm sorry for that little smile we keep allowing to creep onto our faces. I am so, so sorry for the way we put you on the sidelines.

For the pain, suffering and hurt of you, your fellow Howard-boosters and their descendants, we say sorry. To Bolt and Akerman, Henderson and Windschuttle, for the breaking up of the Liberal leadership, we say sorry. And for the indignity and degradation thus inflicted on a proud right-wing people and a proud culture of denial, dog whistles and xenophobia, we say sorry.

Honestly, Andrew, I’m really and truly sorry for you.

Monday, 4 February 2008

Socialist unity in Oz? Two steps forward...?

Well, it's been a while in coming, but the bad running joke of the Australian Left - the existence of not just two, or even three, but FOUR Cliffite groups (that is, groups with politics originating in the International Socialist Tendency) - is over. There's only two now.

On February 2-3, the International Socialist Organisation (ISO), Solidarity, and the Brisbane-based Socialist Action Group (SAG) held a unity conference in Sydney and decided that maybe being in different organisations was a tad silly. After all, they have the same politics (not least a fondness for the nonsense which is State Capitalism), and have been working together (including pre-caucusing before movement meetings) in various campaigns for a while now. This collaboration has been accompanied by a series of joint internal discussion bulletins which, if a wee bit light on the theory, were are least genuinely oriented towards some kind of unity.

The final outcome is a new organisation under the name of "Solidarity", which reflects, if anything, the relative strength of that organisation compared to the other two, particularly in movement work. SAG members apparently argued for a name including the word "socialist", but clearly didn't win. There is likely to be a monthly newspaper, and while the Wombats haven't heard the new paper's name yet, we hope that one of the options floated, "Liberty", gets quickly stymied. Sounds thoroughly daft, in our opinion.

The background to the various splits in the Australian IST would be too formidable a task to go into, except to say that Solidarity left the ISO when it was in the Socialist Alliance, while SAG managed to extricate themselves from the pretty undemocratic propagandist sect-ism of Socialist Alternative (the fourth member of the Cliffite menagerie in Oz). A small group of SAlt members in Sydney left around the same time, joining Solidarity (although two of them soon decided to join the Greens).

The Solidarity split, led by Ian Rintoul, was fiercely anti-Socialist Alliance, so when the ISO finally gave the formal imprimatur to their withdrawal from the Socialist Alliance (a left-unity project, mind you, and one which is ongoing), the biggest barrier to "unity" was overcome. One of the other key features of the new organisation is it's decision to support the Greens in elections, rather than calling for a socialist vote where possible.

This is so despite the nation-wide presence of the Socialist Alliance, and the presence in Melbourne of the Socialist Party, both of which compete in elections; and despite the fact that the internal joint discussion highlighted the inability of the three united groups to have little, if any, impact on the Greens or Greens members during the election campaign. As the Wombats have pointed out here and here, both the Socialist Alliance and the SP approached the ISO last year asking for socialist solidarity around the elections, to no avail.

Socialists do indeed have to work out the best way to work with the Greens, especially those in the amorphous 'left' of the Greens, and there are no "perfect" formulae that are especially better than any others. So the basic idea of Solidarity is hardly flawed in that respect. But ignoring the existence of the rest of the left won't help much when it comes to winning over people caught up in the biggest left-of-Labor political party in history. We need the most unified and vibrant approach possible, and, while the step towards unity is to be welcomed, if it - as seems likely - aims to become yet another competing force on the left, it's unlikely to assist that process.

[One interesting way forward on the Greens question is the ecosocialist reading circle that has been set up in Adelaide, containing members of the Greens, as well as Socialist Alliance, DSP, Communist Party, and others. Dave Riley is preparing an educational series on Climate and Capitalism which could well be used by this group, or by any others for that matter, in conjunction with various forms of socialist/ Green collaboration.]

So, while Bob Gould might think this unification is the best thing since sliced bread, it is still fundamentally limited by what is - if past practice is anything to go by - likely to end up with a certain amount of tail-ending of the Greens, and a sectarianism towards the rest of the organised left - especially the Socialist Alliance. It is perhaps telling that one of the sole voices in the ISO to point out that they might have made mistakes themselves in the early period of the Socialist Alliance (as opposed to blaming everything on the DSP) is in an extreme minority.

The recent unification is still a largely healthy development, however, and we will chart it's development over time.

As if this wasn't enough for one weekend, the Melbourne-based Socialist Party (of the Committee for a Workers' International), has put up on it's website a pamphlet it produced two years ago calling for a "New Workers' Party", and then attempting again to explain why it's simultaneously not actually trying to build one. It's a bit of a read, but for a small group operating only out of Melbourne (even if they do have the country's only elected socialist in Steve Jolley on Yarra council), the tone is all a bit rich, really.

It will be interesting to see, however, whether and how the question of left unity can find new ways forward under the new right-wing Rudd Labor government. There are already plenty of opportunities opening up. The test is, as always, whether we can muster the subjective resources necessary to make use of them. The energy privatisation campaign would be a particularly good one to start with, one would think.

Monday, 28 January 2008

Converge on Canberra: Stand up for Aboriginal rights on Feb 12

Calling all Aboriginal people and supporters to converge on Canberra: Stand up for Aboriginal rights on the first day of the new parliament.

Tuesday, February 12 2008
Meet Aboriginal Tent Embassy 11:30am
March to Parliament for 1pm rally

Turn back Howard and Brough's racist legacy!

- Reinstate the Racial Discrimination Act
- Demand immediate review of the NT intervention
- End welfare quarantines, compulsory land acquisition and 'mission manager' powers
- Implement the UN Declaration on the Rights of Aboriginal People
- Aboriginal control of Aboriginal affairs

In the final months of government, John Howard introduced a package of discriminatory, unfair and punative measures against Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory. Aimed at controlling Aboriginal lives and land, the legislation was a stark violation of basic human rights and dignities.

Federal Labor is promising a new era in Aboriginal affairs. They are pledging to say sorry to the stolen generation and to sign the UN declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People. They have promised to restore both the CDEP (Community Development and Employment Program) and the permit system, which will ameliorate some of the worst effects of the NT intervention.

Unfortunately there are aspects of ALP policy that is still disturbingly similar to the Liberals. Plainly discriminatory measures such as mandatory welfare quarantines, compulsory land acquisition and the presence of non-Aboriginal "business managers" with extraordinary powers are being suffered under right now. There has been no move to allow the operation of the Racial Discrimination Act. The cry for immediate review of the legislation coming from across the NT has been ignored.

The Labor Government must comply with accepted international human rights laws and standards of non discrimination, equality , natural justice and procedural fairness. Legislation being implemented in the NT breaches commitments Australia has made as a signatory to major human rights treaties and conventions; such as the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination and the International Covenant of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The Human Rights Commission must immediately review the legislation to ensure compliance with these obligations.

The federal election revealed overwhelming opposition to the intervention among Aboriginal communities. When Labor MP's in affected areas emphasised political differences to the Coalition they consistently received over 80% of the vote; with 95% in the town of Wadeye.

Despite government claims that the intervention is a response to the Anderson & Wild "Little Children are Sacred" report, no new community-based services to ensure the safety and protection of children have been established, and there has been a notable duplication of services - particularly in the area of child health checks. There is an urgent need for delivery of essential services, infrastructure and programs genuinely targeted at improving the safety and well being of children and developed in consultation with communities. Huge amounts of public money have been wasted, with $88 million alone going towards bureaucrats to control Aboriginal welfare.

Moving Forward
A vibrant, mass convergence Canberra on the first day of parliament will be an important step in challenging the lingering legacy of Howard's racism. We can strongly push for an immediate end to what Aboriginal communities have themselves described as an invasion. We can send a strong signal to Kevin Rudd and his new government to put Aboriginal rights at the centre of their agenda; to massively increase the resources available to communities across Australia and to respect Aboriginal control of Aboriginal affairs.

Initiated by the Aboriginal Rights Coalition, Sydney

Contact:
Shane Phillips 0414077631
Greg Eatock 0432050240

Endorsements from Aboriginal activists include:
Olga Havnen (Combined Aboriginal Organisations of the NT)
Barbara Shaw (Tangentyere council, Alice Springs)
Lez Malezer (Chairman, Global Indigenous People's Caucus UN,
Foundation Aboriginal Islander Rights Association)
Jackie Katona (CEO of Lumbu Indigenous Community Foundation, Djok clan)
Michael Mansell (Tasmanian Aboriginal Centre)
Sam Watson (Brisbane)
Mitch (Eastern Arrernte/Luritja activist from Alice Springs)
Robbie Thorpe (Melbourne)
Phil Falk (Senior Lecturer School of Law, Griffith Uni, Wiradjuri nation)
Linda Murphy (Lecturer, School of Arts, Griffith Uni)
Sandra Phillips (QUT)
Nicole Watson (Jumbunna, Sydney)
Heidi Norman (UTS)
Victor Hardt (Oodgeroo, QUT)
Shane Phillips (Redfern)
Peta Ridgeway (Newcastle)
Arthur Ridgeway (Newcastle)
Greg Eatock (Coordinator Deaths in Custody Campaign, Sydney)
Pat Eatock (Secretary, First Aboriginal Tent Embassy)

Supportive Organisations include:
Women for Wik
Indigenous Social Justice Association
Australians for Native Title and Reconcilliation (ANTaR SA)
Aboriginal Rights Coalition (Sydney)
Intervention Reform Coalition (Darwin)
Intervention Rollback Working Group (Alice Springs)
Alliance for Indigenous Self Determination (Melbourne)
Working Group for Aboriginal Rights (Canberra)
Australian Peace Committee (SA)

Saturday, 26 January 2008

Invasion Day statement, January 26, 2008, by Sam Watson

Invasion Day statement, January 26, 2008, by Sam Watson

Brisbane Indigenous community leader and Socialist Alliance member.

This Invasion Day, 2008, is the opportunity to commence a major change in the position of Indigenous rights in Australia. The time has come to show proper respect and sensitivity to the Aboriginal Stolen Generations, and allow a lengthy period so that there can be consultation across the indigenous communities and all our people are given the opportunity to be involved. The Reconciliation process was allowed 10 years and substantial resources to be undertaken, so the Stolen Generation should be given time for proper consideration.

The Rudd Labor government is showing disrespect for our people and our customs by rushing the process of an apology to the Stolen Generation, in order to serve the larger ALP political agenda. The government wants to make an apology on February 11 and 12, in order for the matter to be resolved and moved off the front pages of the newspapers, so they can concentrate on their bigger game of being re-elected in 2010.

I propose that there should be a national monument erected in front of Parliament House to honor the victims. This moment, when the Australian government offers up an apology will become a significant and defining moment in the short history of this nation.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Aboriginal Affairs Minister Jenny Macklin still haven’t made any attempt to meet with the genuine leaders of the Aboriginal community. We endorse Macklin’s decision to close down the National Indigenous Advisory Council, which is only a handful of Howard’s puppets.

However, the new government now needs to put into practice genuine consultation with the Aboriginal people, in order to make a real apology and to begin to right the wrongs of the past – including offering real compensation to the Stolen Generations.

We must reject the invasion of the Northern Territory by the previous government, and any attempt to extend this intervention to Queensland or other state. We need to seriously challenge Black deaths in custody, and continued discrimination against Indigenous people in all areas of society.

We call on the Australian people to mobilize to defend human rights in all sectors of our country, as well as internationally. Australia needs to recognize that the wealth of this society was gained from the stolen land and resources of the Indigenous people.

Now is the time to remember this history by negotiating a Treaty to truly recognize the rights of the original people of this country, and to provide fair compensation for the theft of their land and resources.

We call on all supporters of Indigenous rights to rally in Canberra, at the opening of federal parliament on February 12, to defend the interests of the Stolen Generations and all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.

For more information, contact Sam on 0401 227 443; or Paul on 07 3831 2644.

www.socialist-alliance.org/brisbane

Monday, 21 January 2008

Match it! An open letter to Kevin Rudd (please sign on)

Match it!

Prime Minister of Australia
Mr Kevin Rudd, MHR [also to other ministers]
January 2008

Dear Prime Minister

Re: Australian and Cuban education assistance to Timor Leste

We the following academics, writers, organisations and NGO workers observe these developments, on education assistance to Timor Leste:

* over 2002-2007 the number of University scholarships offered by the Australian Government to students from Timor Leste declined from 20 per year to 8 per year
* over 2003-2006 the number of medical training scholarships offered by the Government of Cuba to students from Timor Leste increased from 50 to 1,000

There are currently 800 students from Timor Leste studying medicine with the Cubans. This makes it probably the biggest aid program in medical training, per capita, in the world. Adult literacy training in Timor Leste is now also dominated by the Cubans.

So far there have been two Australian reactions (government, media, NGO) to Cuban programs in `our' region. One was to ignore, snipe at or seek to undermine the Cubans, as perceived `competitors' . The other is to respond with a generosity that matches them. We urge your government to strengthen this latter path and MATCH the Cuban scholarship offer.

Cuban health and education programs are recognised and commended by the World Health Organisation and U.N.E.S.C.O. . But Australia also has great capacity to share through its schools, universities and teachers. There is a great deal of goodwill in our country towards the East Timorese, despite the damage done by the oil and gas dispute and the recent crisis.

We urge your government to begin a large scale public education program for the East Timorese, matching the Cuban offer of 1,000 scholarships, in areas in which we have great capacity, such as teacher training. We emphasise that the measure of support should be through the extent of human capacity building, not through a dollar sum.

The ordinary people of East Timor deserve nothing less from a rich and powerful neighbour that has so often let them down.

Yours sincerely
Dr Tim Anderson, University of Sydney
John Pilger, filmmaker and author
Professor Frank Stilwell, University of Sydney
Professor Stewart Firth, Head of the Pacific Centre, Australian
National University
Shirley Shackleton, East Timor activist
Dr Meredith Burgmann, Former President of the NSW Legislative Council
AID/Watch

email: t.anderson@usyd. edu.au; tel: 0418-604-488

Thursday, 13 December 2007

China’s new Labor Laws: employment contract reforms


Chris White reports on Your Rights at Work in China: November 2007

China’s new labor law system on employment contracts promises to protect their precarious workforce from the excesses of capitalism.


The 10th National People’s Congress (NPC) passed Labor Law Contracts on June 29th 2007. They are in force from 1st January 2008.

What are the industrial relations issues addressed? What are the new rights at work?

In Part One, I give an overview of the provisions to regulate employers whose exploitative practices have gone too far. Professor Liu Cheng comments on their likely impact.

In Part Two, I report on the initial compliance reactions. Major corporates prior to January 1st 2008 sought to avoid the new law by dismissing and re-employing their workforce. But now they have been publicly exposed, they have to comply. The role of the All China Federation of Trade Unions ACFTU is stronger.

In Part Three, rather than going down PM Rudd’s collective bargaining road, the debate in China is on a new arbitration system.

Readers may compare these modest Chinese labour law reforms for precarious workers with the reforms from PM Kevin Rudd and Minister for Industrial Relations Julia Gillard for Australia’s precarious workforce.

Australia’s democracy decisively rejected Howard’s WorkChoices. It provided less protection for vulnerable workers than these new Chinese employment contract reforms.

Australia, after the great strikes and lockouts of the 1890’s, turned to arbitration to prevent and settle disputes. The ghost of Judge H. B. Higgins may be shaping China’s labour reforms!

Part One The Reforms and their Impact


I reported in Evatt On-Line in February 2007
[1] on China’s unprecedented public debate in over these new Labor Laws. As well, the US corporations with their neo-liberal ideology lobbied National People’s Congress (NPC) delegates hard to water down the original provisions. They had some success on the details.[2] These labor law contests in China have relevance for workers and their unions’ worldwide.

I returned to Shanghai on October 12th 2007. I followed up a key adviser on the labor laws, Professor Liu Cheng, from Shanghai Normal University, Law and Politics.

Liu Cheng: ‘In the context of globalisation, Chinese labor law is not only something of China its own, but also of America, Europe, and other parts of the world. The trend of “race to the bottom” and deregulation should be deterred by way of global unity. Chinese labor legislation has suffered MNCs’ attack; Chinese labor rights has been endangered by not only Chinese dark-minded employers but also dark-minded employers abroad—such MNCs as Wal-Mart is exploiting Chinese workers by way of driving down acquisition price to make its suppliers non-profitable. This compels the suppliers to exploit workers by way of violating labor law in order to ensure their profit. What’s more, it also hurts fair competition--the dark-minded employers will take advantages of low cost to beat moral employers. It’s apparent that without labor law, there would be no fair competition; without labor law, there would be no social stability.’

I asked about Liu Cheng’s US and Europe visits.
[3]

Liu Cheng: ‘I found it necessary to get support from outside China, to counter the foreign corporations lobby, otherwise there may have been something worse for the Chinese workers. So I made USA visits explaining to the NGO anti-sweatshop lobby, unions and Congress the debates. I argued with four lawyers from the American Chamber of Commerce, but did not convince them.

I received good responses from European unions and NGOs who made contact with National People’s Congress delegates to support the changes. I interviewed some European government leaders, some employer organisations and spoke to about 50 foreign journalists at a press club. European employers now support the new Employment Contract laws…so although the end represents compromise, with some details in the protections for workers and the union role curtailed, it is a victory.’

The provisions apply to all employers. The main reason is to regulate the exploitative employer practices in China’s majority private sector enterprises. Here there are millions of precarious and marginalized workers. In China’s state sector, there is more job security, payment of wages, respect for labour law etc and union consultation, and these new laws still apply.

The key solutions are described. These indicate the industrial relations problems being tackled.

Back pay and no forced labour

It is unbelievable, but such is the capitalist violation of labour rights and the extent of forced labour in China that not only are migrant workers from the countryside in sweatshops factories not paid the minimum wage nor overtime when working seven days a week to finish contracts, but for months not paid at all.

Unofficial strikes over employers not paying wages are widespread. Stories in the Chinese press reveal workers treated as slaves
[4] and ‘wildcat’ strikes and workers beaten to death by company thugs for protesting about not being paid![5]

The new law says wages and overtime have to be paid. The Labor Bureau can direct an employer to pay wages owed within a specified period, failing which an order for damages at between 50 and 100% of the amount outstanding can be made.

Liu Cheng: ‘In the past many employers regarded the labor law requirements to pay wages when due as rubbish, but now employers have to take these new laws seriously, and this is a big improvement. Some 40% of overtime is not paid, so the new law is to ensure overtime and penalty rates are paid.’

Can migrant workers not being paid go to a judge in a People’s Court for an ‘order to pay’?

Liu Cheng: ‘Yes, they can go directly and it should be speedier. The cost of litigation is most important, for if the cost is very high the workers will not be actually protected and the employers can violate the law. The employers have to be punished efficiently if they do not pay the wages and have to take the new law seriously. Although more detailed dispute settlement processes are to be determined later in 2008, this Labour Contract law helps give the worker more protection.’

I read in a China Labor News Translation a report
[6] where a Shenzhen furniture factory worker fought long and hard to get back unpaid two years overtime through the court system.

From no contracts at all to deemed minimum contracts

Liu Cheng: ‘Much past practice in four in five private enterprises in China have not even signed job contracts with their workers. The lack of contracts leaves workers in a legal limbo. This meant work rights were not enforced and no access to the pension fund as there was no proof of an employment contract and the employer denied liability. So now the employment contracts must be in writing and failure to do so means the employer faces liability for double wages. The new law says there is a written contract and provides minimums.’

In 2008, Chinese Courts have to recognise that labor law deems a contract to exist. Minimum wages and conditions are based on comparable collective agreements or regional provisions.

Liu Cheng: ‘Also the Labor Bureau can order damages if the employer refuses to comply…so minimum living standards are much more protected.’

Crack down on forced labour

When hiring workers, an employer may not require them to provide any surety or collect property from the worker as collateral. The employer may not retain the workers’ resident identification cards or other papers.
[7]

So a crackdown is promised on the prevalent practice of forced or bonded labour, in their various disguises. The ACFTU has to unionise these migrant workers. We shall see.

Short-term contracts at an end

Liu Cheng: ‘In many private companies which signed contracts with workers, the duration was often less than one year. Employers concluded employment contracts with the same workers four times in one year. Casualisation is prevalent. The employers refused to sign long-term contracts to avoid legal obligations such as accident pay, health benefits etc.’

‘Now with the new law, after two short term contracts a more permanent open-term contract must be signed. That has to happen so as to prevent many short-term contracts. The third open-term contract then provides for health insurance and the employer is liable for severance pay.

A fixed term contract now has severance pay of one month’s pay for each year of service. Most fixed term contracts can’t be changed by the employer but by negotiation.’

The more permanent contract is also compulsory for those workers with service of no less than ten years, or is ten years away from retirement.

When reemploying after a state owned enterprise has restructured the permanent contract is to be used, as it is when the renewal occurs following the conclusion of a fixed-term employment contract on two consecutive occasions.

Combating casualisation


Provisions regulating part-time work are made. A ‘Part-Time Labor’ category is allowed in the final law, a ‘non-full-time engagement of labour’.
[8] This employment is remunerated by the hour and is terminable at any time without notice or severance pay. But it is restricted to its status, to an average of four hours daily and ‘the maximum remuneration settlement and payment cycle for part-time labor may not exceed 15 days. Article 72.’

This is a legitimate ‘casual’ position. If implemented, it will assist in reducing long-term casualisation, with its many problems.

Probation no longer to be abused

Workers can no longer be on long probationary periods. An employer may stipulate only one probation period with any given worker and not less than 80% of the local minimum. The new standards are: less than one year contract, less than a month probation; 1 to 3 years, 2 months; not less than three years, 6 months.

Transmission of business and contract

The employers cannot avoid liability with a change in the name of the company. Transmission of business also transfers the employment contract, ‘…under the new law, the employment contract will be maintained into the new company…’

Sacking at will to cease

Corporations opposed the termination reforms. These have moved dramatically away from dismissal at will. Employers sought to reduce the costs of terminating workers.

Greater job security is to be put in place for those workers engaged on an ‘open-ended’ regular basis. There are costs for illegal dismissal.

Dismissal is to be allowed only on specific grounds: such as by consent; being incompetent; for serious misconduct; incapacitated by non-work related injury; for mass redundancy (where there are substantive and procedural requirements); and termination by 30 days notice. An employer cannot dismiss for work related injury and e.g. pregnancy.
[9]

The Law enhances the role of the union in the termination process.

Where an employer unit plans to dissolve a labor contract unilaterally, it shall give the trade union advance notice of the reasons. If the employer unit violates the provisions of laws and administrative statutes or the labor contract, the trade union has the right to demand that the employer unit take corrective action. The employer unit shall study the trade union's opinions and notify the trade union in writing of the outcome of its handling of the matter. Article 43.

The social interests of workers in redundancies of over 20 are recognised. Article 41 gives priority for protection for those with long service, those who are the only ones in their families to be employed and whose families have a senior citizen or a minor who needs to be provided for. They have 30 days notice and the circumstances explained to the union.

Are these tougher restrictions an incentive for employers to use avoidance tactics, such as forms other than regular on-going contracts?

Liu Cheng: ‘In theory it looks like this, but in practice they cannot, because of severance pay of one months pay for each year of service for most dismissals. Even with shorter terms, still severance pay applies. And if this does not occur, then the employer has to pay the penalty of double salary to the employee, so in practice the risk is so great and the economic consequences strong. Maybe there will be some employers who use part-time and casual contracts, but most employers won’t put all their employees onto part-time or casual.’

I read reports where employers preparing for the new laws are converting short-term workers into permanent contracts. Others are trying the reverse to pre-empt the changes (see below).

I asked about contracts for project work where severance does not apply. Liu Cheng said most employers would not employ workers on separate projects.

Liu Cheng: ‘ With projects such as building bridges, the employer may conclude one project contract, but may not in practice do more as the employer wouldn’t get labour for the next projects…maybe one off, but not continuously.’

There may be grey areas, where the provisions appear ambiguous. But the employer risks severance pay if dismissing. ‘The cost of violation is very important. The cost will compel the employers to abide by the labour laws.’

Liu Cheng does not think that the more skilled workers will have greater job security over the unskilled. I thought this was the experience in other countries. Will this assist migrant woman?

‘I think in the recent past in China the migrant worker was hurt by the employer, but now their living standard can be improved when the employers abide by the new laws. So now we inform the migrant workers of their rights.’

The ACFTU aims to unionise millions of these migrant workers coming from the countryside into the cities and sweatshop factories.

It is not easy for the ACFTU to move from its servicing model to a new grass roots organising model. There is debate whether this is happening.

Staffing issues: Labour-hire regulated

Employers lobbied against the strong regulation of many labour-hire firms and their use of ‘dispatch’ workers. The new law means there will not be financial reasons for management to sack sections of their workforce to replace them with cheaper labour-hire with ‘staffing firms.’

All dispatch workers from staffing firms must be hired permanently for not less than two years. There is a formal written contract with the same rate and benefits as workers in the user firm in similar work. A minimum wage is paid even when not placed. The worker may join the user firm’s union. Restrictions are a prohibition on user firms ‘on-selling’ dispatch workers to other firms; labour-hire be implemented ‘generally for short-term, supplementary and substitute positions’; and employers may not arrange to have staffing firms to place workers with themselves or their subordinate units.
[10]

Liu Cheng: ‘The employers say that this is very tough, but it is only a slogan. In practice, the assessment of discrimination will be difficult, but the tactics of labour hire firms will not be as discriminatory. The outcome does no longer require the employer to hold money in reserve to cover workers insurance. Nor is there an automatic conversion to a permanent basis.’

Non-competition


The employers’ lobby watered down earlier drafts for workers who leave with a confidentiality clause, a non-compete clause on trade secrets or intellectual property.
[11]

When a professional, skilled or worker who has the obligation to maintain the confidentiality of his employer’s trade secrets, the employer may have a restrictive confidentiality clause. This stipulates the employer shall pay financial compensation to the worker on a monthly basis during the term of the competition restriction after the worker leaves.

If the worker breaches the competition restriction provisions, he shall pay liquidated damages to the employer. There is less compensation for the worker affected, one month’s salary rather than one-year. Geographic restrictions are dropped.

As the Chinese workforce move into more highly skilled technology companies, these restrictions protect existing employers, not the new technology companies. They inhibit the movement of professional and skilled labour.

Liu Cheng: ‘ I think there should have been a ceiling for the damages on the worker and for the compensation to the employer, otherwise employers will take their advantages…to more profitable workers, so, I think there should be more reforms and damages should be lower than three times the yearly wages and the compensation should be no less than 40% of their normal wage, and without such ceiling and floor, it will not be better. In 2008, there will be more detailed rules formulated for these labour laws promulgated by the State Ministry of Labour and Social Security.’

OHS tougher

The lack of compliance to OHS obligations is notorious in China. One new provision is:

‘Article 32 Workers shall not be deemed to be in violation of their labor contracts if they refuse to perform dangerous operations directed in violation of rules and regulations or peremptorily ordered by management personnel at the employer unit. Workers have the right to criticize, report to the authorities, or file complaints against their employer units over working conditions that endanger their lives or health.

Worker and union involvement improved

Major opposition came from employer lobby groups against the earlier draft to require the employer to gain the consent of the employees’ representative works congress and the union to the required changed work rules.

This is watered down to a form of ‘negotiations’. But, still, a form of workplace democracy.

‘Article 4 Employer units shall establish and improve labor rules and regulations in accordance with the law to ensure that workers enjoy labor rights and discharge their labor obligations. Employer units seeking to formulate, revise, or decide on rules and regulations or significant matters that have a direct bearing on the immediate interests of their workers, such as those concerning remuneration, work hours, rest, leave, work safety and hygiene, insurance, benefits, employee training, labor discipline, and work quota management, shall determine the matters through negotiations conducted on an equal footing with trade unions or employee representatives, after employee representatives' conferences or all the employees have held discussions and put forward proposals and comments.’
[12]

Liu Cheng still sees this as an important procedure, as does the ACFTU.

Liu Cheng: ‘This is still a restriction on the employers’ behaviour. Workers and their trade union can indicate if the work rule is inappropriate and the employer is then to make ameliorating amendments to the work rule after consultation. There is a greater role for the local trade union, and if ignored, a higher-level trade union authority is involved. Employers can still be punished if there is no consultation on new company work rules, and may be later found to be invalid and not varied. This procedure is still very important for the workers. The employer may not enforce the work rules if challenged in any arbitral proceeding. There is a greater democratic process for work rules.’

How tough will the Labour Bureau be against employers not complying? How will China’s overly legalistic judicial system respond?

Work conditions on hours, OHS, leave etc are in individual or collective contracts. Employers work rules cannot override them, as contracts are changed only by agreement.

Liu Cheng: 'The problem still is at the moment that most contracts are minimum state wages and standards with little negotiation…China still has a long way to go in many areas, such as more collective bargaining, including in state enterprises…but in some provinces, even in the private sector collective bargaining is changing. I think it needs time.’

Union to Assist and Collective bargaining

‘Trade unions shall safeguard the lawful rights and interests of workers in accordance with the law and oversee the execution of labor contracts and collective contracts by employer units. If an employer unit violates labor laws or regulations or a labor contract or collective contract, a trade union has the right to raise its opinions or demand corrective action. If a worker applies for arbitration or institutes legal proceedings, the trade union shall provide support and assistance in accordance with the law. Article 78’

The enhanced union role, for the ACFTU is important. They are pressed to improve representation over grievances and litigation rights. They are establishing new legal centres.

Liu Cheng: ‘The ACFTU is the only trade union in China, from the period of the planned economy. It’s very strong on the top, while very weak at the grass-root level. In recent years, it has begun to reform. For example, the pilot of direct election of trade union leaders at the grass-root level has been taken for some years, and unionisation such as at Wal-Mart by way of mobilization has also begun.’

The ACFTU wants new legal rights for the election of union delegates at the workplace level. This is because when workers join the union, the employer wants to control the election of the union delegates!

Collective contracts with collective bargaining higher than the minimum wages and conditions are encouraged, as is pattern
[13] or industry bargaining.

‘Article 53 Industry-specific or area-specific collective contracts may be concluded between representatives of trade unions on the one hand and of enterprises on the other hand in such industries as construction, mining, and catering services in areas below the county level.’

The ACFTU is pushing for greater rights for union collective bargaining later in 2008.

I asked that with the requirement of greater consultation with the elected Staff and Workers Representative Congresses (SWRC), would there be greater use of SWRCs to respond to poor management, as in the past in the public sector. Liu Cheng thought this might be only a formalism in the private sector. However, there is scope for a form of Works Council.

Part Two: Compliance or Avoidance?

The state apparatus for compliance is strengthened.

Employers’ legal liability is detailed. These new Chinese ‘Rights at Work’, are to ensure changed employer behaviour and a crack down on the exploitative practices of the capitalists with ‘dark minds’, as Liu Cheng calls them.

The government is educating workers and employers on these laws. In Hangzhou, I read a newspaper for University students explaining their new Rights at Work in 2008.

The Labour Administration departments are given powers to ensure supervision and inspections and are to organise tri-partite compliance rules.

Lawyers for big global companies complain that the new law imposes a heavy burden. ‘It will be more difficult to run a company here,’ says Baker & McKenzie's employment law group, which represents America's biggest corporations in China. Lawyer Mary Margret Utterback, a major corporate law firm, just days before the law’s passage (cited in Global Labor Strategies):

The law is likely to increase the cost of doing business in China. Larger companies will feel the need to have human resources capability in-country. Severance payments, non-compete payments, and the decrease in probationary period length will all increase the employer's labor costs. The undefined role of the labor union may complicate the relationship with management. The ambiguities for justifying a lay-off may also result in increased costs to the employer. Beijing may decide that this is an appropriate time to send the message internationally that the PRC takes labor conditions seriously.’

Other lawyers advised employers there would not be enforcement, as in the past.

Liu Cheng disagreed. ‘In the past, the cost of violating labour laws was very low, but now the cost is higher, so most employers will not prefer to violate the labour laws. …This is a strong national law, but also at the regional and local government level, there has to be enforcement. At the moment, there is publicity on the new laws and I think nearly all employers will see the cost will be much higher and the local authorities have to comply.’

The pressure will be on MNC’s to see their Chinese suppliers comply.

Liu Cheng: ‘I think that the multi-national corporations will be compelled to enhance their purchase price, otherwise most of their Chinese suppliers could not afford to comply and became sweat-shop producers, but this will now change.’

European HR managers say they can comply and one line of legal advice for overseas corporations is that their labour cost increases will stay within a controllable range.

Liu Cheng: ‘…in the long run, their good will towards the workers, will mean they can maintain their profit making process, otherwise they should pay the cost of turmoil or instability.‘

Corporations look at avoidance strategies. From Global Labour Strategies:

‘…it appears that some companies operating in China are already using an avoidance tactic for existing dispute resolutions cases. On June 8, 2007,
the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai sponsored a conference on “China’s Trends” where one influential lawyer representing numerous global firms “promoted using an offshore arbitration clause…” He argued that his firm had a high rate of success in getting foreign business-to-business arbitration awards enforced in Chinese courts. Some favorite arbitration off-shoring locations include Hong Kong and Singapore.

For years global corporations have been moving their operations to whatever country offered the weakest labor and environmental regulations. …if the government passes modestly progressive legislation they'll respond by drafting contract clauses that “ship” the dispute to business-friendly shores. This has been common practice in the US for decades.’

Compliance contest

That this compliance contest is underway is shown by the following reports.

‘ACFTU: Huawei agrees to suspend controversial employment scheme after union talks
www.chinaview.cn 2007-11-10 21.

BEIJING, Nov. 10 (Xinhua) -- China's Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd has agreed to suspend its controversial "voluntary resignation" scheme after talks with trade unions, the All China Federation of Trade Unions (ACFTU) said Saturday.

The ACFTU said it called on China's biggest maker of telecommunications network equipment to protect workers' interests after its plan sparked fears that the company was trying to sidestep a new labor law.

The ACFTU and union organizations called on Huawei to solicit workers' opinions and respect their rights while making regulations related to their benefits.

A company source confirmed on condition of anonymity they had reached a consensus with the trade unions.

The company agreed to suspend the plan but the exact date to implement the suspension will be decided after workers' opinions were solicited at the impending workers' conference since the plan was launched with the consent of workers.

Huawei initiated a plan, calling for its staff who have worked for eight consecutive years to hand in "voluntary resignations", according to the Nanfang Daily, a local newspaper in southern China's Guangdong Province, where Huawei is headquartered.

The staff would have to compete for their posts, and sign new labor contracts with the firm once they were re-employed, while those who lost out would receive compensation.

Officials with the Shenzhen Federation of Trade Unions met with a vice president of Huawei and the two sides reached a consensus on three issues, said an official with the ACFTU on condition of his own anonymity and that of the vice president. They agreed that:

-- The company needed to create a welfare system to guarantee the workers' benefits and rights and in return, the trade unions supported the company's reform and innovation to unite the workers for the company's future development.

The company needed to abide by the law, and to solicit workers' opinions and negotiate with trade unions while making regulations related to workers' rights and benefits.

-- The company needed to consult with the workers on an equal basis while making contracts for workers' pay, workings hours, vacations, work safety and insurance.

The Huawei vice president reportedly said the company always valued the rights and benefits of workers and respected their contributions, said the union official.

Critics said Huawei was making a last effort to avoid signing open end-of-labor contracts with its employees through "voluntary resignation" before the new labor contract law came into effect on Jan. 1, 2008.

Under the law, employees who have worked for an employer for ten consecutive years are entitled to sign a labor contract that has no fixed term, on agreement by both parties.

The new law meant these "veteran" workers would become "permanent" employees, except in circumstances of willful resignation or retirement.

The ACFTU also called for better publicity of the new labor contract law and closer supervision of companies to avoid similar cases occurring.’

Here is the Global Labor Strategies report November 2007:

‘The Battle for Labor Rights in China: New Developments’

Huawei—the Chinese owned telecommunication company with ties to many foreign firms—recently instituted a personnel program widely believed to be an effort to avoid a key provision in China new Labor Contract Law. That provision automatically grants open-ended contracts to workers with either 10 years of service or two consecutive fixed term contracts. Open ended contracts allow workers much more job security—since there is no renewal date and workers can only be removed for just cause—and they provide for more severance pay should a layoff occur. Under Huawei’s program 7,000 long-term workers were offered economic incentives to quit and be rehired on 1 to 3 year fixed term agreements. The layoff program was widely reported in the Chinese press and roundly criticized by labor rights advocates inside and outside the government.

Now, under intense pressure from the public and the All China Federation of Trade Unions (ACFTU), China’s sole legal union, Huawei has suspended the program.

There is a widespread sense that many firms are engaging in similar practices as they position themselves for life under the new law.

And it's not just Chinese owned firms. Wal-Mart has also come under scrutiny in the Chinese media for some staff reductions. Wal-Mart said that the reshuffle of its employees is not aimed at the new labor law. …but more than 100 employees had been laid off, including 40 in Shanghai and 60 in Shenzhen. A woman who works in the Shenzhen center, said she has been working there for four years and was laid off last month. She was told she would receive three months salary plus some additional compensation. She said she expected to be off for one to two months before returning to the company.”

Back at Huawei, the
Asia Sentinel reports on how pressure was applied to long time workers:

We were called into our supervisor’s office about one month ago”, an unnamed Huawei employee who has been working with the electronics company since 1999. “We were encouraged to voluntarily resign within two weeks. My stock will be kept for six months. If I can get reemployed by the company, then I can get the stock back. Otherwise, I’ll be paid cash.”

It is not clear from press reports what will happen to the employees who have already resigned. But the official news agency
Xinhua reports, officials with the Shenzhen Federation of Trade Unions met with a vice president of Huawei and the two sides reached a consensus on three issues (see above.)

In what may be a sign of the times in China, despite efforts to mask the layoff programs as legitimate corporate restructuring schemes, many people weren’t fooled. The official on-line news service
China.org reports:

A recent survey, organized by the Investigation Center of China Youth Daily, shows that 42.7 percent of the 2,212 interviewed applaud Huawei's staff reforms, while 57.3 percent do not.

According to the survey, opponents consider this a display of capital power, because "the employees working more than 10 years at Huawei are the backbone of the company, and they are the most important for the survival of the enterprise. Huawei's attitude toward its 'veteran' workers will definitely make the company less attractive to talented professionals."

The survey further found,

….87.4 percent of the respondents believe the new law does not provide excessive protection for employees, while 69.4 percent think the protection is not enough.

Nearly 70 percent feel that employees don't have the power necessary to protect their rights.

In the wake of the Huawei controversy the government and the ACFTU have issued warnings to both Chinese and non-Chinese companies on compliance.

The ACFTU reports that it has “…carried out probes….” to pre-empt evasive actions. The
China Daily reports,

Chang Kai, an official with the Legal Affairs Office of the State Council, asked the companies to study the law properly before initiating a move against it…..

"The national and local legislatures, the State Council and government agencies will soon issue judiciary interpretation and guidelines to stop employers from trying to dodge the law," Chang said.

According to the interpretation, a firm will be seen as trying to dodge the law if it prompts mass resignation, 21st Century Business Herald quoted him as having said. And "violators will have to pay a heavy price."

The controversy and highly publicized cases like Huawei may be good news for a number of reasons.

First, while some companies are worried about the law and are conducting covert campaigns to circumvent its impact, the government and the ACFTU seem serious about its implementation. This could be a step in the direction of establishing the rule of law in China.

Second, what happens at big companies like Huawei could have a ripple effect, at least in some industrial sectors, by setting the tone for what happens at smaller firms. One HR official at a smaller IT company, quoted by
China.org, says, “I have paid great attention to Huawei’s ‘voluntary resignation scheme’ since the beginning…. I want to know how relative departments will deal with…. problems so we can use [it] as a reference in the future.”

Third, the agreement reached at Huawei looks a lot like conventional collective bargaining. Of course, whether and what kind of bargaining actually takes place will depend in part on the actions of the ACFTU which, to date, has generally worked in close collaboration with management—indeed, is often staffed by managers. The ACFTU could become an agency to help impose the new law in China’s workplaces and economy, or it could continue to be just a vehicle for quieting down worker upheavals. Time will tell.

Finally, the Labor Contract Law may function like the National Labor Relations Act did when it was enacted in the US 70 years ago, defining rights that employers try to ignore, evade, or repress—thereby creating the conditions in which workers demand implementation of the rights that they have been told they possess. We may be witnessing an early skirmish in that battle.’

Other reports give a balanced assessment of adjusting to doing business in China.
[14] Important changes for making profit in China.

No Right to Strike

I was cited in the China Biz news that Chinese workers are not to have the right to strike.
[15]

‘On the lawful strike to protect workers, the right to strike, the ACFTU are not in favour. They see their task as more consultation, negotiation and prevention of disputes. Wildcat strikes and social workplace disturbances, public protests e.g. against unpaid wages are on the increase and not organised by the union, but where the union has to settle the dispute with a return to work.

…there is now quite some reluctance on guaranteeing the right to strike in the law. Chinese know the routine of striking all too well, White notes:

“There is neither a lawful right to strike or for strikes to be illegal, so there is both tolerance and repression, where strike leaders are arrested not for organising the strike but usually some trumped up criminal offence or disturbing the peace.”

So, the debate is on, but what is most likely going to happen in the short run? In China's campaign-like style of pushing forward change, we are probably going to see public tests in getting collective agreements in place, probably with some foreign enterprises as guinea pigs. It is not going to be a revolution, nor a dramatic change for most companies. It is going to be an interesting learning process, both for the Chinese trade union and the companies involved.’

I asked, as I had read
[16] that shortages of labour mean a turning point for the Chinese economy.

Liu Cheng: ’its mainly in some advanced technics markets, but not in the market as a whole where labour is a surplus driving growth. In some areas yes, such as the Pearl River delta area. But even here it is not real labour shortages, it’s owing to the wages are so low workers won’t come to work. It will still be ten or twenty years until there are labour shortages.’

Part Three: A New Dispute Settlement Law: A Mediation and Arbitration System

First, there is Chinese tripartism.


Article 5 The labor administrative departments of people's governments at or above the county level shall, together with trade union and enterprise representatives, establish a sound tripartite mechanism for coordinating labor relationships and jointly study and resolve major issues concerning labor relationships.

Next, new labor process laws will come later in 2008. There is a first draft of a new Labor Settlement Disputes law, ‘Mediation and Arbitration of Labour Dispute’ submitted to the National People’s Congress on August 26, 2007 (I have a copy).

The focus is on a reformed dispute mediation and arbitration system. Chinese workers lack the right to strike, so arbitration is one of the few institutional ways for workers to address workplace grievances.

The mediation and arbitration law is to address a number of government concerns.
According to the China Daily, PRC figures reveal that:

‘Labor dispute cases in China are continuously increasing in recent years. Statistics show that labor dispute arbitration organizations at various levels dealt with 1.72 million labor dispute cases involving 5.32 million employees from 1987 to the end of 2005, with a growth rate of 27.3 percent annually.’

‘New law will give workers free arbitration in labor disputes (China Daily October 25, 2007)
[17]
Arbitration services for employees in labor disputes will be provided free of charge if a new law is given the go-ahead. Draft of the law on mediation and arbitration of labor disputes…proposes public funds cover the cost of arbitration committees. It also says employers must present relevant evidence to the committees as required or face punishment.

…the granting of final decision-making powers to arbitration committees in three kinds of cases. These are: disputes over labor payments, workplace injuries, compensation and pensions; disputes over holidays and social security; and disputes over collective contracts.

The current regulation, adopted by the State Council in 1993, comprises a dispute-settlement process of mediation, arbitration and a trial. The new procedure aims to greatly shorten the time taken to settle labor disputes and cut costs," Yang Xingfu, a standing committee member of the congress, said.’

Liu Cheng is critical of the details of this first drafting.

‘In my opinion, the principal problems with the first draft are as follows: First, the mediation procedure is in disorder and has no binding force; second, the relationship between arbitration and litigation is the same as that of civil procedure which is employer-friendly; third, there is no proper litigation procedure.’

Global Labor Strategies explains.
[18]

‘Under the current arbitration system, workers are granted access to the court system only if arbitration fails. And many companies have gamed the system by delaying proceedings. According to a
recent article in the Beijing Review:

Against a backdrop of intensifying tension between labor and management, people have begun to question the 20-year-old arbitration solution. The major complaint is that it takes a long period to reach a verdict…The confirmation of employment relations and the appraisal of work injuries usually have to be conducted several times between arbitration and trial, which explains why in some extreme cases the whole process has taken 19 years. The biggest victims of these slow procedures are usually the employees, who often badly need compensation from their employer for medical treatment or simply to buy food and other necessities.

Many legal experts and senior lawyers have expressed worry that arbitration more often than not will give a verdict favoring the interests of management and sometimes this is a result of bribery. In other cases, the arbitration committee, which is heavily influenced by the government, will refuse requests for arbitration from employees under the government call for creating a favorable environment to attract investment. Such a response has also eliminated any judicial means for workers to safeguard their interests.

At least a few of the provisions are pro-worker. These include:
• Ensuring that workers can petition courts for cancellation of unfair arbitration judgments or parties’ failure to comply;
• Extending the deadline for initiating arbitration from 60 days to six months from the day the parties know or should have known of the harm;
• Mandating that if an arbitration court fails to deliver verdict within 45 days workers may file a lawsuit in People’s court;
• Granting workers the right to petition the court to take enforcement measures if employers refuse to comply with mediation agreements on wages, benefits or work injuries (although this right appears to be severely limited by the fact that if the employer answers the charge in writing, the enforcement order abates).

Chinese labor scholars are far from pleased with the initial draft and are pushing for major revisions.

We know for sure there is at least one major flaw in the law...and it’s a big one. The current draft is silent on the majority of Chinese labor arbitration disputes. According to Professor Chang Kai, a distinguished labor law scholar based at Renmin University and drafter of the Labor Contract Law: "The current law is drafted for solving the labor disputes of individual workers rather than those involving a group of workers. But in reality, a lot of labor disputes concern a group of workers."

Recent studies show that group labor disputes have been on the rise and now represent roughly 60% of all workers involved in disputes. Professor Chang argues that the new law needs to be grounded in China's existing realities by elevating the importance of group labor disputes: "If the law remains focused on solving individual labor disputes, in 10 years we will have many problems that cannot be solved under the current legal system."

I understand that the Labor Arbitration bureaucrats are resistant to change and want to continue their (inadequate) role. We shall see what model prevails.

Sexual harassment regulations

In regulations, Guangdong province explicitly require employers to establish investigation and complaint procedures to protect women against sexual harassment. The regulations require employers to create secure safe work environments. This is part of the Law of the Protection of the Rights and Interests of Women. I read a newspaper report where the Professor of Law, Beijing University, was promoting these requirements; another important workplace debate.

Party leadership support Labor laws

With the recent 17th National Communist Party Congress, Hu Jintao, Party Secretary and President of China, consolidated his political leadership. He stressed how important these new labour laws are for his ‘harmonisation’ in industrial relations in China’s unique ‘socialist market economy’.

This CCP leadership generation promise more focus on human as well as economic development; economic development balanced with environmental action; regional disparities between western and central regions to develop as in the coastal eastern sectors; crackdown on corruption; tackling gross inequality of wealth; social security measures dealing with inequality; and these new labor laws. These are fascinating times.

Who is to prevail, the Chinese political leadership or the corporations? Whether Hu Jintao’s ‘scientific development with Chinese characteristics’ prevails will be known soon.

After WorkChoices?

As China’s competitive production puts downward pressure on wages and working conditions, these IR outcomes are of great relevance for Australian working families.

Australian Companies have to comply with these new laws. PM Rudd should insist.

Liu Cheng said it is important with corporate globalisation that overseas unions visit China and discuss these IR issues and be a balance to the corporate world’s influence.

He said there would be soon the first US AFL-CIO delegation visiting China. Other US unions have visited regularly, including Change to Win delegations.
[19] Australian unions are increasingly being asked to visit and engage on these IR issues.

These labor laws are also important in the negotiations over an Australia-China Free Trade Agreement, now to be negotiated by a Rudd government.

One reason that Howard’s WorkChoices went down badly with workers and with voters is that Howard lied when promising protection or fairness for an increasing numbers of precarious Australian workers, casuals, out-sourced, in labour hire, and those in enterprises less than 100 who can be unfairly dismissed, restructured and made redundant.

Arguably, China’s modest labor laws afford some workplace social justice to workers and are better than in WorkChoices.

It is going to be interesting to see the modest rights for Australia’s precarious workers to get a ‘fair go’ and collective bargaining reforms from PM Kevin Rudd and Deputy PM Julia Gillard.

Australia and China’s industrial relations reforms have different social, workplace and political contexts. Nevertheless, our IR debates and contests over strategies are reasons to participate and compare the ongoing campaigns over rights at work.

November 23 2007

Chris White is a Labour Law and Industrial Relations writer living in Canberra. References
whitecd@velocitynet.com.au

[1] I use the English translation of the Labor Contracts from the Beijing Xinhua Domestic Service -- China's official news service, New China News Agency. In February 2007, I attended a Beijing Industrial Relations conference and interviewed those involved in the new Labour Laws. My Evatt Foundation report is ‘China’s New Labour Law The challenge of regulating employment contracts. China moves beyond WorkChoices,’ http://evatt.labor.net.au/publications/papers/193.html. My interview with the All China Federation of Trade Unions ACFTU ‘Organising China’s Wal-Mart’ Evatt Foundation http://evatt.labor.net.au/publications/papers/194.html
See an analysis of these new employment contract provisions in the November 2007 UNSW Law Journal. The November 2007 Journal of Industrial Relations volume 49, number 5, has the issue on China. See, e.g. on the background to China’s labour law, Sean Cooney “China’s Labour law. Compliance and Flaws in Implementing Institutions.’ Page 673. For earlier China labour law, Ying Zhu, Economic Reform and Labour Market Regulation in China, in Law and labour Market Regulation in East Asia 177 (Sean Cooney et al. eds. 2002). Sean Cooney, ‘Making Chinese Labour Law Work: The Prospects for Regulatory Innovation in the People’s Republic of China’ (2007) 30 Ford ham international law Journal 1050, 1081-1086. Also, Rolf Geffken (2006) Labour and trade unions in China (European Trade Union Institute for Research, Education and Health and Safety). Kan Wang (2007) A Changing Arena of Industrial Relations in China What is happening after 1978 Renmin (People’s) University of China, Beijing.
[2] See Global Labor Strategies on the contest between corporations and NGOs and unions ‘Behind the Great Wall of China. U.S. Corporations Opposing New Rights for Chinese Workers. Opposition may harm workers in the U.S. and other countries.’ www.laborstrategies.com For their 20/2/2007 reply to the corporate lobby, see JapanFocus.org Earl Brown ‘Chinese Labor Law Reform: Guaranteeing Worker Rights in the Age of Globalism’ JapanFocus 24/11/2006; ‘Multinationals Accused of Hypocrisy over China Labour Law Reform’ International Textile, Garment and Leather Workers’ Federation (ITGLWF) 26/10/2006.
Global Labor Strategies:
http://laborstrategies.blogs.com/global_labor_strategies/2007/07/chinas-new-cont.html Update October and November2007.
[3] Reports on Liu Cheng’s US visits http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2007/04/03/280/ His papers are available from the author.
[4] ‘Shanxi Scandal Gives Urgency to Draft Labor Contract Law.
Chinese lawmakers deplored the forced labor scandal uncovered in north
Shanxi Province and recommended that the top legislature urgently ratify the labor contract law and thus better ensure the legal rights of employees.
… the investigation found that 2,036 of the 3,347 brick kilns had been devoid of any legal licenses and collectively employed 53,036 illegal workers. (The story was exposed first by Chinese bloggers).
This scandal had emphasized the needs for stronger protection of employees' legal rights. Items of the draft labor contract law could be applied to illegal labor cases such as the one in Shanxi.
The forced labor scandal… sparked public outrage and grave concern among the upper echelons. The workers were treated as slaves, forced to work long hours without payment in brickyards, mines and other small works. Shanxi provincial governor Yu Youjun has formally apologized over the forced labor scandal, promising to use his full power to root out any more cases of such illegal practices. (Xinhua News Agency June 25, 2007)’ http://www.china.org.cn/english/GS-e/218983.htm
[5] Worker Beaten to Death over Pay Strike. One unpaid migrant worker was beaten to death at a building site in Guangdong Province and hundreds of his workmates who were striking to get delayed salaries were injured by thugs the building owner hired. The attackers, armed with shovels, steel pipes, axes, and knives, injured many of the strikers and killed Lei Mingzhong, a laborer from Kaixian County. Nearly 300 workers went on strike at the site after working for four months without payment, because the owner, a subsidiary of Shenzhen based Fuyuan Energy Group, had delayed paying the contractor millions of yuan. Having failed to coerce the workers to end the strike, Fuyuan then hired hundreds of thugs to fight them and force them back to work. Ye was reported to have led the thugs when they rushed the workers and beat them. The workers, most of who were reported to have been empty-handed, suffered injuries in the fierce attack, even after police arrived at the scene. Lei was killed while two of his workmates were forced to jump from a high wall into the Dongjiang River. The thugs even threw rocks into the river after them, the newspaper said. Fuyuan Hydropower Co, a subsidiary of Fuyuan Group, plans to build a hydroelectric power station on Dongjiang River. With a total investment of 316 million yuan (US$41 million) from Fuyuan Group, the power plant is expected to produce 90 million kilowatt hours a year.
Miao Shouliang, the boss of Fuyuan Group, was listed as the 19th richest real estate tycoon last year by Rupert Hoogewerf, a former Forbes China employee who established his own luxury business listing company — Hurun Report — in Shanghai. Miao denied delaying the payment of money to the contractor but hung up when reporters asked him to comment on the incident. (Shanghai Daily July 2, 2007).
http://www.china.org.cn/english/China/215751.htm Earlier: China Daily 31/12/2006 ‘Migrants frustrated over unpaid wages’ about anger over ‘the death of a young rural worker who was beaten up last week while claiming unpaid wages…’
[6] CLNT translated two articles: the first is a newspaper report on the case with a brief comment from a legal expert; the second is the worker’s own description of the process, published in an NGO magazine. These are available from this author.
[7] Article 9; Chapter two Conclusion of Contracts.
[8] Chapter V. Section 3 Part-Time Labor. Articles 68, 71.
[9] Chapter IV Dissolution and Termination of Labor contracts; article 39; article 42; 44.
[10] Articles Staffing services 57 to 62. Article 66. Article 67. It will be interesting to see how these are enforced.
[11] Chapter Article 24
[12] Article 4; also chapter vii Legal Liability
[13] WorkChoices outlawed industry bargaining industrial action. This breached ILO Conventions. Kevin Rudd’s policy is also in breach. Check my guest blog at ‘What limits the right to strike?’ http://larvatusprodeo.net/2007/05/21/guest-post-by-chris-white-what-limits-the-right-to-strike/

[14] There are many legal firms and consultants advising: e.g. Global Risk Alert from AON Global; and lawyers King and Wood www.kingandwood.com; Baker and McKenzie www.bakernet.com
[15] http://www.cbiz.cn/news/showarticle.asp?id=2458
[16] Ross Garnaut & Ligang Song. ‘The Turning Point in China’s Economic Development’ (2006 Asia Pacific Press).
[17] http://www.china.org.cn/english/government/229625.htm
[18] http://laborstrategies.blogs.com/global_labor_strategies/2007/10/chinas-new-draf.html
[19] The US union movement split at the top, with now the ALF-CIO and the Change to Win, already invited into China by the ACFTU.